Poetry

A perennial hobby of mine is translating historical poetry into modern English, just for fun. I am under no illusions about how good these translations are, I know they're bad; I mostly do them for the fun and the process.

Classical Chinese

花非花 - Flowers Aren't Flowers

白居易 - Bái Jūyì

花 非 花
雾 非 雾
夜 半 来
天 明 去
来 知 春 梦 几 多 时
去 似 朝 云 无 觅 处

Flowers aren't flowers,
Fog isn't fog.
Midnight comes,
Bright sky goes.
Coming like spring dreams, for how long
Going as the morning clouds, untraceable

Thoughts

This poems nicely illustrates a gripe I have with a lot of translations of Tang poems in specific, and Classical Chinese poetry more generally. Almost every translation I checked of this poem adds a subject 'she' to the last two lines, and some add 'she' the preceding lines as well. 'She comes like spring dreams' and 'she goes like the bright sky.' If Bai Juyi had wanted to put in a subject, he could have (in point of fact, he essentially never does). English gerunds and simple presents are even still more specific than the open ambiguity of Bai Juyi's verbs, but in my opinion they maximally avoid putting things into the poem that aren't there.

池上 - Chí Shàng - On the Pond

白居易 - Bái Jūyì

山 僧 对 棋 坐
局 上 竹 阴 清
映 竹 无 人 见
时 闻 下 子 声

On the mountain, monks at chess sit facing
Shadowed still bamboo over the board
The shining bamboo no person sees
Sometimes hearing the sound of a lowering piece

Thoughts

This one was really pretty difficult. It is unclear to me the exact relationships between consituents in some of these lines, and I'm still unhappy with some of the word translations - 'still' for 清 is correct, in the sense of being unmoving, which I feel works well to parallel the the stillness of the monks and to contrast the small movements of the pieces. However, it carries the unfortunate temporal meaning of 'still' in English, which is not in 清.

臨江樹 - Lín Jiāng Shù - Trees Overlook the River

魚玄機 - Yú Xuánjì

翠色連荒岸
煙姿入遠樓
影鋪秋水面
花落釣人頭
根老藏魚窟
枝低繫客舟
蕭蕭風雨夜
驚夢復添愁

Blue-green links the desolate banks
Misty forms enter and exit the mansion
Shadows spread on the autumnal water's surface
Flowers drop on fishermen's heads
Old roots conceal the caves of fish
Low branches arrest guests' boats
Dreary, dreary, wind and rain and night
Startling dreams return and replenish anxiety

Thoughts

I find the poetry of Yu Xuanji endlessly arresting. She has an immediacy that is sometimes lacking in the tenseless and floaty images of Tang poetry in general. She's also a very interesting historical figure, and worth looking into. One of a small number of female medieval chinese poets whose work we have, she lived at different times as a concubine and a courtesan and Daoist nun. Her name is interesting, the very rare surname 魚 'fish', and the personal name 玄機, which might be translated as 'Arcane Secret', 'Profound Theory', or 'Mysterious Principle'. She traveled widely on her riverboat as a nun, and much of her poetry reflects themes of water and travel and her various sexual encounters with men and women on these trips. She was executed at about 28 in circa 868.

书事 - Shū Shì - A Study

王维 - Wáng Wéi

轻阴阁小雨
深院昼慵开

坐看苍苔色
欲上人衣来

Gentle cloud on the pavilion, and light rain
Wearily opening the afternoon courtyard
Sit and look at the color of green moss
Wishing for people's clothing to come up

Thoughts

This one mystifies me a little, I have to admit. I have no idea what he means in the last line. The words, in order, literally mean 'to want/intend' 'up/above' 'people' 'clothing' 'come'. Is he going to pick up people's clothes in the pavilion? Is he comparing the color of the moss to the pretty clothes? Why do so many other translators translate 欲 as 'about to' when it is clearly a verb?

山居秋暝 - Shān Jū Qiū Míng - Autumn Twilight at Home in the Mountains

王维 - Wáng Wéi

空山新雨后
天气晚来秋

明月松间照
清泉石上流

竹喧归浣女
莲动下渔舟

随意春芳歇
王孙自可留

The empty mountain after fresh rain
Autumn's weather comes late

The bright moon softly lights the room
From the clear stone spring rises the river

Noisy bamboo belongs to the washerwomen
Lotus stirs below fishing boats

As they please, spring flowers take it easy
For noble children remain among themselves

Thoughts

This poem hits a lot of themes very common in Tang poetry (seasons, weather, the moon, water), but it executes them so well, it's one of my favorites. I particularly love the metaphor of spring flowers on the riverbanks as indolent children of the nobility.

Regress to the Starting Point